When stock stop drinking from a trough that has water in it, the cause is usually what is in or on the water: dust, algae and the smell it gives off, warm still water, or salt. NSW DPI Primefact 326 puts it simply: the consumption of water can be affected by the cleanliness of the watering point. It also warns that contamination of trough water need only be very slight to cause problems with some stock.
Dust: a thin film is enough
The most striking example in the Primefact is this one: instances have been recorded of weaner sheep refusing water because of a thin layer of dust on the surface of an otherwise clean trough. Nothing was wrong with the water underneath. The film on top was enough.
That is why troughs in yards, laneways and containment pens, where stock kick up dust all day, need more attention than a paddock trough on grass.
Algae and odour
The Primefact says troughs used in watering systems should be drained and cleaned regularly, because algae grow in troughs, producing unpleasant odours in the water which can repel stock. Algae respond to sunlight and fertilisers, and blooms are most likely when the water is still, warm and high in nutrients. In a trough, feed carried in on muzzles is one obvious source of those nutrients.
Blue-green algae are the bigger worry, because a number of them are toxic. The Primefact deals with them mainly in farm dams, but the same conditions, still and warm water with nutrients in it, apply in a neglected trough.
Warm, still water
Water temperature changes how much stock drink. The Primefact says animals generally prefer water at or below body temperature and avoid warmer water, and that cool water is preferred in hot conditions. A small volume of water sitting in the sun all afternoon is the opposite of that.
Goats are fussier again
Goats are known for it. The NSW Department of Education's goat guidance says water supply must be clean, as goats will refuse to drink dirty or contaminated water. If you run goats and sheep, assume the goats will be the first to tell you a trough needs cleaning.
Salt: the problem a clean trough cannot fix
Salinity is different from dirt, because it comes in with the water. But troughs make it worse: the Primefact notes that salinity builds up due to evaporation if troughs are not drained, and that marginal water can become unsatisfactory in summer as evaporation from troughs and shallow tanks lifts the salt level.
Agriculture Victoria publishes salinity tolerance levels for stock water. The first column is where production decline begins, which the page describes as the upper limit salt concentration for healthy growth. The second is the maximum level that may be safe for limited periods.
| Stock | Production decline begins | Maximum, limited periods |
|---|---|---|
| Lactating ewes and weaners | 3,800 mg/L (6,000 EC µS/cm) | 6,400 mg/L (10,000 EC) |
| Dry mature sheep | 6,000 mg/L (9,300 EC) | 14,000 mg/L (21,800 EC) |
| Beef cattle | 4,000 mg/L (6,250 EC) | 10,000 mg/L (15,600 EC) |
NSW DPI's Primefact gives a slightly different set for sheep: a desirable maximum of 5,000 mg/L, and 10,000 to 13,000 mg/L as the maximum that may be safe for limited periods, depending on the type of feed. Both agree on the main point. Young animals, heavily pregnant or lactating females, and aged or weakened stock are less tolerant of saline water, so set your limit by the most sensitive class in the mob.
For goats, the MSD Veterinary Manual says total dissolved solids under 1,000 mg/L is considered safe for all livestock, 1,000 to 5,000 mg/L is satisfactory, and over 10,000 mg/L should be avoided. It also flags soluble sulfates, which should be under 500 mg/L.
If your water test reports electrical conductivity rather than mg/L, the Primefact gives the conversion: EC in µS/cm multiplied by 0.67 gives total dissolved solids in mg/L.
pH
Water with a pH below 6.5 or above 8.5 can cause digestive upsets, rejection of the water and depressed appetite, according to the Primefact. Worth testing at the same time as salinity if you are on bore or dam water.
Watch the first week
The Primefact's advice when stock meet a new paddock or an unfamiliar watering system is to make sure they know where the water is and are drinking it, and if water quality is marginal or unknown, to check newly introduced stock during the first week. The same applies when you change troughs.
Keeping the trough out of the equation
You cannot clean salt out of the water, but you can stop the trough adding to the problem. Draining and cleaning regularly removes dust, algae and the salt concentrated by evaporation, and the Primefact says how often depends mainly on temperature and on the class of stock. A self-flushing trough is one way to drain the trough on a schedule between hand cleans. The SATURN trough we sell holds 50 litres, uses approximately 60 litres per flush at one to two flushes a day as suggested by the manufacturer, and refills through a mechanical float valve. More frequent emptying may help keep the water fresher, but it will not change what comes out of the bore. These are manufacturer figures and we have not published any trial results.
What we recommend
If stock are hanging back from a trough, look at the surface first, then smell the water, then get a salinity and pH test if you are on bore or dam water. Set your cleaning routine by the season and the fussiest class in the mob. If you want to see whether a self-flushing trough reduces your cleaning, test it on your own farm first through our 3-month trial in Victoria.
- NSW Department of Primary Industries, Primefact 326 Water requirements for sheep and cattle, third edition (2014), archived copy
- Agriculture Victoria, Feeding Livestock: Sheep water calculator, salinity tolerance table
- NSW Department of Education, Animals in schools: Goats, food and water
- MSD Veterinary Manual, Nutritional requirements of goats
- Manufacturer information, SATURN trough specifications (cleantrough.com.au/product)