If you are replacing troughs, the features that decide how long cleaning takes are the shape, how smooth the inside is, whether there is a large drainage outlet with somewhere for the water to go, what the trough sits on, and whether you can reach the fittings. Agriculture Victoria puts it in one line: a long shallow trough with a smooth internal profile, gate valve and large outlet bung will make cleaning quick and efficient. The MLA feedlot design manual works through the same features in detail, and most of what it says applies to a paddock trough as well as a feedlot pen.

Long, narrow and shallow, not big and round

MLA is blunt about shape. Long, narrow, shallow troughs are preferable to large, deep, high volume circular troughs, because the volume of water tipped into the pen with each flushing is minimised by using low volume troughs. Rectangular troughs fit along fence lines, are more easily cleaned inside, are easier to clean around with machinery, and provide more linear space than a round trough of the same capacity.

Size it before you buy. MLA sets a minimum of 25 mm per head of available linear trough space in normal weather and 75 mm per head in hot conditions. Agriculture Victoria says a trough for 500 sheep or 160 cattle would have 8 to 10 metres of accessible edge and hold 400 to 600 litres.

The inside surface

MLA notes that the inside of a concrete trough gets harder to clean over time as it deteriorates through hardness of the water, cattle licking, saliva, enzymes in feed stuffs and mechanical cleaning. It can be protected with a fibreglass or polyethylene insert, or by coating the surface with an epoxy resin, best applied when the trough is new. If you are ordering concrete, that decision is made now or not at all. Agriculture Victoria still rates concrete the preferred material for its durability, strength and ability to hold water at a more constant temperature.

A drainage outlet, and somewhere for the water to go

MLA requires each trough to be fitted with a large drainage, or flushing, outlet, positioned so the water flows away from the trough and preferably into a drain. One common arrangement is a stand pipe you unscrew to open the discharge bung. Troughs are cleaned by flushing out the old water, then adding more while you scrub.

MLA warns that pipework carrying the water away clogs with stones, grain and debris unless it has good slope, over 1 per cent, and no sharp bends, and recommends extra flushing time to clear sediment. In a paddock the question is the same: does the dirty water run away from where stock stand, or back into the mud.

Underneath and around the trough

Sides should be vertical and closed in, running from the top of the trough down to the apron. Open framed bases let manure build up underneath, which encourages flies, promotes odour and makes cleaning more difficult.

MLA calls a concrete apron at least 3 metres wide all around the trough essential in what is a high traffic area. Three metres allows full access and supports the full 2.4 metre width of pen cleaning machinery. Aprons should slope at least 2 per cent away from the trough and have a non slip surface. Outside a feedlot, Agriculture Victoria's version is a raised pad of gravel, stone or concrete for drainage and stability.

Fittings you can reach

Float protection has to be sturdy, either an open weldmesh frame or preferably fully enclosed, and covers must be easily removable so you can reach float valves and gate valves. Remember a float cover takes up part of the drinking length. Agriculture Victoria prefers a trough where all the fittings are fully enclosed within the trough design.

Keep it away from the feed

After feeding, cattle hold grain on their muzzles and in their mouths, so a trough close to the feed collects more grain and needs cleaning more often. Agriculture Victoria says it plainly: locate troughs away from feeding areas.

What we recommend

Shape, surface, outlet and apron are what you are really buying, so check those four before you compare prices. Whatever you install, Agriculture Victoria's advice to empty, clean and refill every 1 to 2 days does not change, so be honest about who will do it. Our SATURN trough is 2,225 mm long, holds 50 litres and flushes about 60 litres out the drain at the far end on a schedule you set (manufacturer figures). To see whether that suits your water and your stock, test it on your own farm during our 3-month trial in Victoria.

Sources
  • Agriculture Victoria, Water supply in stock containment areas (agriculture.vic.gov.au)
  • Meat & Livestock Australia, Feedlot design manual, chapter 20 Water trough design and sewer systems (2016)
  • Manufacturer information, SATURN trough specifications (cleantrough.com.au/product)